12/10/99
By Bill Gannon, Mathew Futterman,
Ted Sherman and Robin Gaby Fisher
STAFF WRITERS
A small twin-engine plane approaching Teterboro Airport
crashed and burned between two homes in a Hasbrouck Heights neighborhood yesterday,
killing all four people aboard.
The plane, a six-seat Beechcraft Baron, fell out of the
sky into the middle-class neighborhood of single-family homes on tree-lined streets, then
burst into flames. It demolished a garage and charred a cluster of pines in a back yard at
17 Washington Place before careening into the back of a home in an adjoining yard. The
family who lives in the home was away on vacation.
According to the Federal Aviation Administration, the
flight had originated from Hanover County Municipal Airport in Virginia, north of
Richmond. Officials said two men and two women were on board.
The names of the victims were not immediately disclosed.
But Gregory P. Stoneman, the owner of the plane, said from Virginia that his friend, Chip
Brierre, and another friend had borrowed it for a flight yesterday. He did not know if
either was on board at the time of the crash.
Brierre's father, Roland, of Richmond, said his son, 41,
and his son's wife, Cary, had taken off yesterday from Hanover County Airport, near their
Richmond home, to attend a party hosted by a fishing acquaintance in New York City.
Authorities would not confirm that Brierre was one of the
victims.
Three were killed immediately from the crash. The fourth,
ejected from the plane upon impact, survived until 9:50 p.m., when he was pronounced dead
at the Hackensack University Medical Center, officials said.
Michael Aragon, who lives four houses from the crash, said
he ran into the back yard where he saw the man sitting on the ground a few feet from the
wreckage, with his arms and legs on fire. The man looked up at Aragon and said:
"Please help me. Please help me."
Aragon said he shouted for neighbors to bring water, and
then an explosion in the plane prevented him from getting close to the man again. "It
was too hot," Aragon said.
Frank Armeli, a Hackensack fireman who lives in Hasbrouck
Heights, and his neighbor, Albert Kopec, ran to the burning man, whom they found sitting
in a circle of flames. One of the two took his coat off and tried to beat out the flames
before dragging the man through the fire to rescue workers.
The man was taken to the Hackensack hospital with second-
and third-degree burns to 100 percent of his body, according to John J. LoCurto Jr., the
doctor who directs the trauma department. LoCurto said the man was talking when he was
brought in, complaining that he was in extreme pain.
Three others were also taken to the medical center: Armeli
with burned hands, Kopec with a mild concussion, and Keith Bruining, a Hasbrouck Heights
firefighter, for smoke inhalation. All were treated and released.
Witnesses said police and firefighters began arriving at
the crash site literally seconds after the plane hit the ground.
One police officer at the scene said the pilot had
contacted the Teterboro tower and reported that he was disoriented and losing control of
the plane.
The plane disappeared from FAA radar screens at 5:32 p.m.,
said Bob Hancock, the air safety investigator for the National Transportation Safety
Board.
According to the FAA, the aircraft was a 19-year-old
Beechcraft Baron 58TC. The pilot had filed a flight plan and was cleared to land on Runway
19 at Teterboro when he crashed two miles south of the airport. The weather was mild, with
5 mph winds and 10 miles visibility.
Reached by telephone in Mechanicsville, Va., Stoneman, the
plane's owner, reacted with shock when told of the crash.
He said he knew of three on board "There should have
been a professional pilot flying it," Stoneman said. "It was loaned to two
friends."
Brierre's father said his son owns Commonwealth Boat
Brokers in Glen Allen, a Richmond suburb. Brierre said his son and daughter-in-law have an
8-year-old son who was staying with him last night.
The elder Brierre said he could learn almost nothing from
New Jersey authorities last night and didn't know what to tell his grandson.
"It's very troubling to us," he said. "I
don't know what to do."
In Hasbrouck Heights, the crash shattered the holiday
atmosphere of a neighborhood already glowing with menorahs and Christmas lights, sending
flames and sparks above the tall oak trees. "The neighborhood lit up like the Fourth
of July," said Margaret Canestrino, who lives on Washington Place.
"I thought my house exploded," said Joanne
Minervino, who lives about two blocks from the crash site.
"Then when I looked outside I saw smoke behind my
neighbor's house. The whole house shook. Everybody's house shook."
Several people witnessed the plane's abrupt descent.
"I saw these lights and they were kind of spiraling
down. I thought, 'Is that really a plane? What the hell is that?" said Vinnia
Schwartz, 34.
Chris Seppentino, 25, a sixth-grade teacher, was taking a
walk a block away when he heard a rumble, looked up and saw the plane fly over his head,
its wings wobbling.
Moments later, "there was a brilliant white flash of
light; then a second or two later there was a tremendous explosion -- it was a huge
boom."
An 11-year-old girl, Olivia Barton, said her whole house
shook: "I almost fell on the ground, it shook so much."
Canestrino, a school bus aide, was on her front porch,
about to leave to go shopping, when she heard "a huge bang." "It sounded
like a cannon going off," she said. "I walked fast down the street and I could
see tremendous smoke and showers of sparks, and then I could see all the fire reflected in
the houses. The smoke was intense."
According to the NTSB, this was the eighth fatal plane
crash in New Jersey this year. Before yesterday, 12 people had died in small-plane crashes
since Jan. 11. The last fatal accident took place in a Newark neighborhood the day after
Thanksgiving, when a family of three from Bethesda, Md., crashed in fog soon after their
Beechcraft Bonanza BE35 took off from Linden Airport. Preliminary reports indicate the
pilot lost critical instrumentation.
The last fatal crash near Teterboro was in January, when a
twin-engine Cessna 310R crashed minutes after taking off on an air-courier flight to
Wilmington, Del.
Pilot Ronny Wachter was killed when the plane nose-dived
into the Conrail shipping yard in Kearny. He reported control problems shortly before air
traffic controllers lost contact with him. The accident is still under investigation by
the NTSB.
The safety board said it would review voice and radar
tapes today of the Hasbrouck Heights crash.
Staff writers Rebecca Goldsmith, George Berkin, P.L.
Wyckoff, Ana Alaya and Jeffrey C. Mays contributed to this report.